We all take an interest in the careers -- and the career moves -– of others, but when it comes to movie stars, our fascination is lifted to a whole new level. We feel a sense of ownership over certain characters, real and fictional. And though we may not work in the entertainment business, there’s something about our deep involvement in the movies that makes us think we know what's best for Hollywood actors -- what roles they should take, where their careers should go next, which directors they should work with (or never work with again). That kind of armchair directing is part of what's so great about the movies.


Still, it's worth admitting that, as a collective audience that loves to obsess over every decision our favorite stars make, we're not always right. Sometimes, in fact, we're dead wrong. (This, too, is part of the magic.)


Whatever else you may think of them, here are five actors who were initially slammed for taking roles that ended up defining their careers. Some of them even managed to respond to the criticism with grace and humor -– perhaps knowing their work would do most of the talking.


Robert Pattinson





Even "Twilight" author Stephenie Meyer wanted someone other than Robert Pattinson to play Edward Cullen, the franchise's lead vampire. (Meyer had hoped future Superman Henry Cavill would snag the role[1] , but he was too old by the time it was optioned.) "[It was] unanimous unhappiness," Pattinson recalled about the outcry after he was cast[2] . Things worked out for the actor, however: "Twilight" was a global sensation, and Pattinson has used his post-franchise fame to work with acclaimed directors like Werner Herzog, David Cronenberg and James Gray.


Daniel Craig





After Daniel Craig was cast to replace Pierce Brosnan as James Bond in 2006, 007 devotees slammed the actor as both too short (Craig is the smallest Bond ever at under six-feet) and too blonde[3] . Seven years later, though, and Craig has led the Bond franchise to its largest box office receipts ever. (Last year's "Skyfall" was the first Bond film to cross the $1 billion mark in global ticket sales.) Craig is so beloved now that he'll appear as Bond in two more films[4] .


Michael Keaton





Michael Keaton is looked upon as one of the best actors to ever play Batman, but when he was cast in Tim Burton's 1989 film, would-be supporters were initially irate. "I don't get the importance," Keaton told Grantland in an interview last year when asked about the backlash[5] . "I was doing an interview, and the guy was going on and on about it, and finally I said, 'Did you read the paper this morning?' And I wasn't being a smart ass, I was just being real. And he goes, he just said yes or no, I don't know. I said, 'Do you know there are bodies literally, literally like a logjam floating down rivers in Rwanda right now from being hacked up and killed -- right now?' and he goes, 'Oh, that's terrible ...' And I'm like, 'Who gives a f--k who's going to be Batman?'"


Heath Ledger





Heath Ledger's performance as The Joker in "The Dark Knight Rises" is regarded an all-time great (Ledger won a posthumous Academy Award for Supporting Actor for his work), but as with Keaton, fans were unhappy after he was hired. "God, talk about REALLY bad casting," one commenter wrote[6] at the time.


Jennifer Lawrence





Everyone loves Jennifer Lawrence now, but when she was cast as Katniss Everdeen in "The Hunger Games," the affection toward her was mixed. (Lawrence's hair color and physical description was not in line with how author Suzanne Collins wrote her protagonist.) "The cool thing about Katniss is that every fan has such a personal relationship with her, and they understand and know her in a singular way," Lawrence, then 20, told Teen Vogue[7] . "I'm a massive fan too, so I get it." All's well that ends well: Lawrence is now one of the world's biggest stars, and it's hard to imagine "The Hunger Games" working without her.



Also on HuffPost:




Loading Slideshow...



  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Selena Gomez attended the Flaunt Magazine En Garde Issue launch party held at Hakkasan in Beverly Hills, Calif., on Nov. 7.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Ben Affleck and Jennifer Garner stopped by Starbucks before heading to pick up their daughter Violet from school in Santa Monica, Calif., on Nov. 7.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Natalie Portman was seen leaving the "Good Morning America" studios in NYC wearing bright pink on Nov. 7.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Ariana Grande arrived at the BBC Radio One studio in London, England on Nov. 7.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Jennifer Lawrence (and Jennifer Lawrence's new pixie cut) answered fan questions on Tumblr Chat during a Q&A session at Yahoo! headquarters on Nov. 6 in Sunnyvale, Calif.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    The adorable cast of "Girl Meets World," Ben Savage, Danielle Fishel, Rowan Blanchard and August Maturo, posed for wonderful photo booth photos on Nov. 6.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Gisele Bundchen attended the 2013 WSJ Magazine's "Innovator Of The Year" Awards at the Museum of Modern Art in NYC, Nov. 6.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Jodie Foster was seen leaving Matsuhisa restaurant in Beverly Hills on Nov. 6.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Newly single (and still stunning) Miranda Kerr jetted out of LAX on Nov. 6.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Charlie Day got goofy on the set of "Horrible Bosses 2" in Los Angeles, Calif. on Nov. 6.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Rebecca Romijn and husband Jerry O'Connell celebrated her 41st birthday with dinner at Hakkasan restaurant on Nov. 6.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Miranda Lambert rocked a little black dress at the 61st annual BMI Country awards on Nov. 5 in Nashville, Tennessee.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Jessica Biel stunned in white and gold at the Museum of Modern Art 2013 Film benefit: A Tribute To Tilda Swinton on Nov. 5 in NYC.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Jennifer Garner looked breathtaking in all white at a Max Mara red carpet event in Tokyo on Nov. 5.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    <em>That's</em> how she stays in shape! Eva Longoria spotted on a morning jog in the Hollywood Hills on Nov. 5.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Kate Upton struck a pose during Melbourne Cup Day at Flemington Racecourse on Nov. 5 in Melbourne, Australia.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Blake Lively texted on her pink Moto X while hanging with her dog Baxter in Los Angeles, Calif. on Nov 5.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Jennifer Lawrence touched down at LAX Nov. 4, less than three weeks before "Hunger Games: Catching Fire" opens in theaters.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Pierce Brosnan and Salma Hayek filmed a romantic scene for "How To Make Love Like An Englishman" on the beach in Malibu, California on Nov. 4.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Whoa! Jaimie Alexander attended the premiere of Marvel's "Thor: The Dark World" on Nov. 4 in Hollywood in quite the revealing number.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Paris Hilton touched down at LAX on Nov. 4 in stylish leather pants.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Michelle Trachtenberg, in a gorgeous green gown, and Will Rothhaar attended the "Killing Kennedy" Los Angeles premiere on Nov. 4.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Reese Witherspoon had lunch at The Ivy in Santa Monica, Calif., on Nov. 3.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Taylor Swift attended the BBC Radio 1's Teen Awards at the Wembley Arena in London, England on Nov. 3.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Pregnant Gwen Stefani took her sons to Racer's Edge Indoor Karting in Los Angeles, Calif., on Nov. 2.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Lana Del Rey and Barrie James O'Neill attended NYLON magazine's party at the Sunset Marquis Hotel in Hollywood on Nov. 1.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Hilary Duff was spotted grabbing pre-workout coffee before heading to the gym in Los Angeles on Nov. 1.




  • Celebrity Photos: November 2013


    Justin Bieber waved to his fans from the balcony of Copacabana Palace in Rio de Janeiro on Nov. 1.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Zoe Saldana and husband Marco Perego looked totally in love walking around Los Angeles, Calif. on October 31.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Kelly Osbourne embraced the dark side (and posed with her father, the Prince of Darkness) for Bootsy Bellows' Halloween party on October 31 in West Hollywood.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Heidi Klum outdid herself with this old woman costume for her annual Halloween party, October 31 in NYC.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Carmen Electra chose sexy for Bootsy Bellows' Halloween party on October 31 in West Hollywood.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 31


    Nicole Scherzinger dressed as Catwoman for Jonathan Ross's Annual Halloween party on October 31 in London, England.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Matt Lauer dressed up as CJ, Pamela Anderson's character on "Baywatch," for the "Today" show Halloween special, Oct. 31.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Sigourney Weaver attended the American Ballet Theatre Opening Night Fall Gala at Lincoln Center, NYC, on October 30.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Bethenny Frankel, dolled up in pink, threw a princess themed Halloween party for her daughter and her friends on October 30 in New York City.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Nicky Hilton wore a stunning blue floor-length gown to the American Ballet Theatre Opening Night Fall Gala at the David Koch Theatre in NYC, on Oct. 30.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Maria Menounos looked gorgeous in white at the Oceana’s Partners Awards Gala 2013 held at the Beverly Wilshire Hotel in Beverly Hills.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Blake Lively was seen leaving her hotel in Paris in mismatched prints on October 30, after being announced the newest face of L'Oreal.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Lady Gaga spotted leaving her hotel dressed head to toe in black, complete with an oversized hat and mask on October 30 in London, England.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Nicole Richie stunned in an an all-white ensemble at Chloé's first Los Angeles Fashion Show on October 29, after which she received the Chloé signature fragrance.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Joe Jonas and girlfriend Blanda Eggenschwiler went for a walk through the East Village in NYC after grabbing lunch on October 29, amid reports the Jonas Brothers have broken up.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Liam Hemsworth arrived on a flight at LAX Airport on Oct. 28 in Los Angeles, Calif.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Melissa Joan Hart was seen out and about in New York City on Oct. 29.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Amanda Seyfried and Justin Long joined forces at the Patron-sponsored LAByrinth Theater Company Celebrity Charades Benefit on Oct. 28 in NYC.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Hailee Steinfeld attended the "Enders Game" premiere held at the TCL Chinese Theatre in Hollywood, Calif., on Oct. 28.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Kate Bosworth and her husband Michael Polish made the media rounds to promote their new film on Oct. 28 in New York City.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Tom Hiddleston, Natalie Portman and Chris Hemsworth attended the "Thor: The Dark World" Germany premiere at CineStar on Oct. 27 in Berlin, Germany.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Anne Hathaway got into the Halloween spirit as she decorated her house with spider webs and a ghost on Oct. 27 in Los Angeles, Calif.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Angelina Jolie took her kids to pick up Halloween supplies in Australia on Oct. 26.




  • Celebrity Photos: October 2013


    Michelle Williams attended the 2013 Whitney Gala & Studio Party in New York City, New York on Oct. 23.