Guppies and water fleas live only days or weeks, but their mortality increases sharply with age, as is the case in longer-lived animals such as humans. But other animals — such as the hermit crab, the red abalone and the hydra, a microscopic freshwater animal that can live centuries — buck that trend, enjoying near constant levels of fertility and mortality.


A comparison of standardized demographic patterns across 46 species, published Sunday in Nature [1] , suggests that the vast diversity of ‘aging strategies’ among them challenges the notion that evolution inevitably leads to senescence, or deterioration of mortality and fertility, with age, says Owen Jones, a biologist at the University of Southern Denmark in Odense, who led the study.


“By taking a grand view and doing a survey across species, we found plenty of violations of this underpinning theory,” says Jones.


To compare fertility and mortality patterns, the authors assembled published life-history data sets for 11 mammals, 12 other vertebrates, 10 invertebrates, 12 vascular plants and a green alga, and standardized the trajectories — dividing mortality rates at each point in the lifespan by the average mortality rate.


They found no association between the length of life and the degree of senescence. Of the 24 species showing the most abrupt increase in mortality with age, 11 had relatively long lifespans and 13 had relatively short lifespans. A similar split in lifespan occurred in the species that had a less abrupt increase in mortality.


When the researchers organized the species along a senescence continuum, mammals were clustered at one end of the spectrum, among the organisms that have an abrupt shift in mortality, and plants, which boast vastly lower relative mortality, populated the other end. Birds and invertebrates were scattered throughout.


The authors suggest that the diversity of aging strategies across the spectrum should challenge theoreticians. “The [evolutionary] theories we have are applicable in lots of situations — but they can’t explain some cases,” says Jones. “It’s not about throwing out old theories; it’s about modifying theories to work on all species.”


Species salad


This is the first attempt to standardize cross-species comparisons of mortality and survivorship, but it has several scientists scratching their heads because, they say, the diversity of life strategies is well established. More importantly, they question the biological basis of the comparison.


At issue is the validity of comparing lab-raised, sometimes inbred, populations to field studies, some of which go on for decades. “This approach is like making a fruit salad and imagining it can tell you something about evolution of the orange,” says Steven Austad, an evolutionary biologist at the University of Texas Health Science Center in San Antonio. “This comparison of demographic trajectories across the tree of life is completely divorced from biology and ignores the impact of the environment,” he adds.


Laurence Mueller, an evolutionary biologist at the University of California at Irvine, agrees. “Organisms in the field die from a lot of causes — for example, predation or disease — other than aging,” he says. “Unfortunately, the unknown source of mortality in field-data sets confounds the age-related patterns of senescence, which is what we’re all interested in,” he adds.


Study co-author Hal Caswell, a mathematical ecologist at Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in Massachusetts, says that attempting to distinguish whether or not deaths are senescence related is a mistake. “An increase in mortality with age represents a decline in the ability to deal with hazards of death, regardless of their source, and is defined as senescence,” he says.


But the critics interviewed by Nature say that they doubt this paper presents a formidable challenge to evolutionary theory. “This study is a useful reminder that the patterns of aging are diverse, but it is not a refutation of existing theory,” says Stephen Stearns, an evolutionary biologist at Yale University in New Haven, Connecticut. “That would require difficult empirical measures of the trade-offs between reproduction and mortality, which haven't yet been done.”


This story originally appeared in Nature News[2] .



Also on HuffPost:




Loading Slideshow...



  • Strongest Animal


    The rhinoceros beetle (pictured) can push around 850 times its weight.




  • Largest Invertebrate (Land)


    The coconut crab weighs about 6.6 pounds and its legs can span up to two and a half feet

    Liz Hall from the Melbourne Aquarium inspects Coconut Crab as he takes possesion of a coconut in Melbourne, 19 December 2006. They Coconut crab (also known as the Robber Crab) are the largest living crab in the world and can climb coconut trees to harvest coconuts which they can break with their huge nippers and have been gruesomely know to feed on injured or unconcious people in the bush. (William West, AFP / Getty Images)




  • The giant squid is the world's largest invertebrate, and the largest ever measured was 59 feet long. Giant squids also have the largest eyes of any animal, each one about the size of a human head.




  • Smallest Mammal


    The etruscan shrew is the smallest mammal (by weight) in the world. The smallest animal by skull size is the bumblebee bat.




  • Most Venomous Animal


    The sea wasp jellyfish (pictured) has enough venom to kill 60 adult humans.
    Photo: <a href="http://www.flickr.com/people/65578066@N00" target="_hplink">Guido Gautsch/Flickr</a>




  • Longest Migration


    Arctic terns migrate about 11,000 miles to the Antarctic each year...and then come all the way back!

    An Arctic Tern dives down to protect its nest on June 24, 2011 on Inner Farne, England. (Dan Kitwood, Getty Images)




  • Loudest Animal


    Blue whales' low-frequency pulses can be heard over 500 miles way. At 188 decibels, these sounds are louder than a jet engine.

    In this picture taken on March 26, 2009, shows a blue whale swimming in the deep waters off the southern Sri Lankan town of Mirissa. (Ishara S. Kodikara, AFP / Getty Images)




  • World's Most Extreme Animals


    North African ostriches run up to 45 miles an hour, making them the fastest land bird. They are also the biggest, weighing up to 345 pounds.

    An african ostrich eats at the Addo National Elephant Park, north of Port Elizabeth, on June 24, 2010. South Africa is hosting the 2010 FIFA World Cup. (Patrick Hertzog, AFP / Getty Images)




  • Fastest Bird


    Peregrine falcons dive toward their prey at over 200 mph.

    A young male Peregrine Falcon eats meat taken from the protective glove of Taronga Zoo bird trainer Erin Stone (unseen) following a short flying lesson in Sydney on December 9, 2009. (Greg Wood, AFP / Getty Images)




  • Fastest Fish


    Sailfish can swim at speeds of up to 68 mph, although experts disagree as to just which species of sailfish is the fastest.

    Sailfish jumping out of the water on January 16, 2006 in the Florida Keys, Florida. (Ronald C. Modra, Sports Imagery / Getty Images)




  • Fastest Mammal


    Cheetahs can run at speeds up to 70 mph.

    Majani, a 2-year-old male African cheetah, exhibits lighting speed Friday, March 19, 2004 while chasing a mechanical rabbit at the San Diego Zoo's Wild Animal Park as part of the Park's environmental enrichment program. (Ken Bohn, San Diego Zoo / AP)




  • Longest Lifespan


    Three giant tortoises are estimated to have lived over 175 years, with one estimated at a whopping 255 years.

    Image: Harriet, who died in 2006, was thought to be the third longest-lived tortoise on record.
    <a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/doctorow/123660557/" target="_hplink">Cory Doctorow/Creative Commons</a>




  • World's Most Extreme Animals


    African elephants are the heaviest and second tallest land animals. Large males can exceed 13,000 pounds and are 12 feet tall at the shoulder.

    This photo made on February 10, 2011 shows an elephant in Tsavo west national park, some 350 kilometres southeast of Nairobi. (Tony Karumba, AFP / Getty Images)