NEW YORK -- Monster Beverage is suing San Francisco's city attorney over demands that the company reduce the amount of caffeine in its energy drinks and stop marketing to minors.


The company, based in Corona, Calif., says it's being unfairly singled out by City Attorney Dennis Herrera, who late last year had asked Monster to produce documentation showing that its drinks are safe. Since then, Monster says Herrera has asked it to reformulate its drinks and change its labels and marketing materials.


A representative for the city attorney's office, Matt Dorsey, said "we're aware of the lawsuit and the city attorney is evaluating his options." He added that Monster's marketing "flies in the face of emerging scientific consensus about the safety of highly caffeinated energy drinks."


The suit comes at a time when the energy drink industry has come under intense scrutiny. Herrera's office got involved in the issue after the Food and Drug Administration said last year that it was investigating reports of deaths linked to energy drinks, which sparked a wave of bad publicity for the industry. The federal agency has noted that the reports don't prove the drinks caused the deaths.


New York's attorney general has also subpoenaed Monster – as well as the maker of 5-Hour Energy shots and PepsiCo Inc., which makes Amp – as part of an investigation into how energy drinks are made and marketed. In addition, the family of a 14-year-old girl is suing Monster; the family says she died after drinking two 24-ounce cans of Monster in a short period.


Monster meanwhile has stood by the safety of its drinks. Earlier this year, the company hit back at the lawsuit, noting that there was no blood test performed to confirm that the girl died of caffeine toxicity.


In its lawsuit against San Francisco's city attorney, Monster Beverage Corp. cites a letter from Herrera dated March 29 asking the company to reformulate its product to "lower the caffeine content to safe levels" and to provide "adequate warning labels".


Monster's current label says people should limit themselves to one can every four hours and a maximum of three per day. It also says the drink isn't recommended for children, people sensitive to caffeine, pregnant women or women who are nursing.


But the city attorney said in his letter that three cans amount to 480 milligrams of caffeine, nearly five times the recommended maximum for adolescents and more than the 400 milligrams per day the FDA has indicated is safe for adults.


Although some brands of coffee contain more caffeine than Monster's energy drinks, Herrera also noted that coffee is typically served hot and consumed slowly. Energy drink makers, by contrast, specifically market to youth and encourage them to "pound down" their drinks in large quantities, the letter said.


Even as soda consumption has flagged in recent years, energy drinks including Red Bull and Rockstar have surged in popularity. In 2011, sales volume for energy drinks rose by nearly 17 percent, according to Beverage Digest, an industry tracker. That growth slowed to about 14 percent in 2012 and has slowed even more dramatically for the early part of 2013, said John Sicher, publisher of Beverage Digest.


Meanwhile, caffeine is turning up in other foods, including jelly beans, waffles and Frito-Lay's Cracker Jack'd coated wafers that include two tablespoons of ground coffee. On Monday, the FDA said it would investigate the safety of added caffeine and its effect on children and adolescents.


The investigation was prompted by the introduction of a gum by Wrigley that has as much caffeine as a half a cup of coffee in one piece.


In a statement, the FDA noted that it was taking a fresh look at the potential impact that "the totality of new and easy sources of caffeine" may have on health, particularly children and younger consumers.


The FDA noted the only time it explicitly approved the added use of caffeine in a food or drink was in the 1950s for colas.


___


Follow Candice Choi at www.twitter.com/candicechoi


Also on HuffPost:






  • Bananas


    Bananas have always been a popular food with athletes, thanks to their calorie-dense, portable nature and abundance of potassium -- an electrolyte lost during intensive sweating sessions.
    <br><br>
    But researchers from the Appalachian State University's Human Performance Lab <a href="http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0037479" target="_hplink">recently found</a> that endurance cyclists performed just as well when they consumed bananas as they did when they drank a sports drink.
    <br><br>
    What's more, the banana offered other, long-term benefits not available from a sugary sports drink: antioxidants, fiber and vitamin B.
    <br><br>
    The study was funded by Dole, a fruit company that sells bananas, but it was also published in the peer-reviewed journal, PLoS ONE.




  • Chocolate Milk


    Sports drinks are meant to give you a mid-workout boost, and they're also intended to help with recovery. But recent research found that low fat chocolate milk -- yes, the plain old, dessert-like dairy drink -- works better than the neon stuff.
    <br><br>
    <a href="http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/sports-drinks/MY01209" target="_hplink">According to a Mayo Clinic review</a> of several high-quality studies, that's because low fat milk has all three components required for proper sports recovery: carbohydrates, in the form of lactose; the electrolytes potassium and sodium; and protein, from casein and whey.




  • Coconut Water


    Coconut water is sometimes touted as "nature's sports drink" -- and while it's true that the drink is full of the electrolyte potassium and is lower in calories than most sports drinks, that moniker is a bit of hyperbole.
    <br><br>
    Athletes need potassium, but they also need sodium, which isn't in sufficient enough quantities in commercial coconut water. <a href="http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/08/08/really-the-claim-for-better-hydration-drink-coconut-water/" target="_hplink">Explains Anahad O'Connor</a> at the New York Times' Well Blog:
    <br><br>
    <blockquote>An 8.5 ounce serving of Vita Coco 100% Pure Coconut Water, for example, contains 30 milligrams of sodium and 15 grams of carbohydrates. An eight-ounce serving of Gatorade Pro 02 Perform is equal in carbs (14 grams) but has more sodium (200 milligrams).</blockquote>

    But for moderate activity or gym sessions under an hour, where replacing water is the primary concern over replacing electrolytes and sugars, the low-cal, all natural beverage is a better bet.




  • Raisins


    In addition to sports drinks, many companies now offer sports gels or "chews" -- a solid, no less colorful gelatin confection that delivers sugars, electrolytes and calories.
    <br><br>
    But in <a href="http://www.runwashington.com/news/763/309/The-Athlete-s-Kitchen-Sports-Nutrition-News-from-ACSM.htm" target="_hplink">a study of trained cyclists</a>, raisins -- an all-natural and far cheaper option -- performed just as well to help athletes sustain their energy and performance when eaten as a pre-training snack.
    <br><br>
    Elizabeth Applegate recommends trying out other kinds of dried fruit too -- figs and pears are particularly great because of their high carbohydrate content, she said.




  • Homemade Drink


    "Liquid really makes the most sense during the workout. Blood flow goes to the muscles, so digestion is slower. The easiest thing to digest is a liquid," says Barbara Lewin, RD, LD, a sports nutritionist who works with professional and Olympic athletes, as well as "regular" gym-goers.
    <br><br>
    Lewin shared her go-to mix for a healthful, natural alternative sports drink.
    <br><br>
    <strong>Natural Sports Drink Recipe</strong>:
    <br>
    3.5 cups water
    <br>
    1/4 cup orange juice
    <br>
    1/4 cup maple syrup
    <br>
    1/4 teaspoon salt
    <br><br>
    An eight-ounce serving provides 50 calories and 110 mg sodium, according to Lewin.




  • Rice


    It might seem surprising -- and certainly messy! -- but UC Davis' Elizabeth Applegate explains that cooked rice, especially squirted with a bit of honey, makes a good energy-delivering, restorative snack for endurance athletes.
    <br><br>
    "Of course, this isn't appropriate for runners," she told The Huffington Post, recommending the mix for cyclers.




  • Caffeine


    While endurance athletes need the electrolytes and carbohydrates that come from a sports drink, most often, regular gym goers do not. That's because under an hour of moderate-to-intense exercise doesn't warrant concerted replacement efforts.
    <br><br>
    Most often, when your average gym warrior goes for a sports drink, they really just need a pick-me-up. And for that, suggests Elizabeth Applegate, a low-cal drink with 100 milligrams of caffeine -- like a black iced coffee or strong tea, will work just fine.
    <br><br>
    <em>
    <strong>CORRECTION</strong>: An earlier version of this slide stated that caffeine should contain 100 grams, rather than milligrams. That would be a dangerous amount of caffeine. We regret the error. </em>