PARIS (AP) — A pair of researchers who gave the French revolutionary Robespierre a disputed 3D makeover raised the possibility Friday that the man best known for unleashing the Reign of Terror may have suffered from a rare autoimmune disorder.


Using a death mask that some historians believe was taken by Madame Tussaud herself just after Maximilian de Robespierre was guillotined, the researchers constructed a pockmarked, malevolent face that bears little resemblance to portraits of the revolutionary leader.


Researchers Philippe Charlier and Philippe Froesh, in a letter in the British journal Lancet published Friday, said their review of the death mask and descriptions of Robespierre's ailments by contemporaries indicate he could have had sarcoidosis, a rare autoimmune disorder that was first recognized in 1877, nearly 100 years after the revolution.


Some historians question the mask's authenticity, including Philippe de Carbonnieres, a historian at the Paris' Musee Carnavalet, home to one of the most famous portraits of Robespierre as a handsome young man, with a clear gaze and no sign of facial scarring. Copies of the mask can be found at the Granet Museum in the southern city of Aix-en-Provence.


Tussaud knew Robespierre and many of the other revolutionaries and created death masks in exchange for keeping her own head during tumultuous times, but Carbonnieres said she certainly faked Robespierre's, describing the woman who ultimately fled for Britain as "something of a show woman."


"This is a vision that a lot of people want to have of Robespierre," said Carbonnieres, who himself is a member of the organization Friends of Robespierre.


The whole argument might seem academic, but Robespierre remains a hugely divisive figure in current French politics. When the first 3D images emerged earlier this month, far left politicians denounced it as a plot to make their hero look evil.


"These days, with 3D, heroes are derided and tyrant kings are magnified ... A sad era," wrote Alexis Corbiere, a Paris official and member of the Leftist Front, which is among many to view Robespierre as a champion of social justice.


Corbiere referred to the recent dispute about the head of French King Henry IV, prompted by the same researchers, who did a 3D reconstruction of the monarch's head from a skull that other researchers ultimately said was misidentified. They have continued to stand by that work.



Froesh said many in France still lionize Robespierre as a founding father and can't bear to think of him as ugly.


"They say that it doesn't correspond with the portraits of the era, which show no scars," Froesh said. "When they see this picture of a tired man, with bags under his eyes and scars, people are disappointed because it shatters their idealized image of Robespierre."


Guillaume Mazeau, a historian of the Revolution at the Sorbonne, said it was unlikely that Tussaud would have had time to make a death mask of Robespierre, whose remains were disposed of as quickly as possible by his rivals during the Reign of Terror, which saw tens of thousands of executions in less than a year. The mass executions diminished after Robespierre was guillotined.


Robespierre's health problems were well documented, Carbonnieres said, and Werner Stenzel, a research physician who studies sarcoidosis, said the speculation seemed reasonable given the symptoms he reportedly suffered, which included fatigue, jaundice, nosebleeds, leg ulcers and frequent skin problems.


"You cannot provide the proof obviously with case which is that old," said Stenzel, of Berlin's Charite hospital, one of Europe's biggest. "The conclusions that can be drawn must be prudent, and this was certainly done in this case."


Fake or not, Mazeau said the 3D image and the strong reactions to it are striking.


"It's not neutral, this face. I don't even know if they're aware of it, but it has a political message," he said. "It comes from the view of Robespierre as a monster, whose face inspires fear, and it keeps with the tradition of counterrevolutionary caricature."


And Robespierre himself is no neutral figure in France, well beyond his death at age 36 in 1794.


"It is a question of the impact of the French Revolution in the long-term," Mazeau said. And to re-open questions about his health "are metaphors, revealing in the minds of some the nation's health."


___


Follow Lori Hinnant at https://twitter.com/lhinnant



Also on HuffPost:




Loading Slideshow...



  • James Parkinson


    James Parkinson (1755 – 1824), apothecary surgeon, geologist, and political activist, first described 'paralysis agitans,' a condition that would later be renamed Parkinson's disease.




  • Aloysius "Alois" Alzheimer


    The German psychiatrist Aloysius "Alois" Alzheimer (1864 – 1915) published the first case of 'presenile dementia' -- what we now call Alzheimer's disease.




  • Hans Asperger


    Hans Asperger (1906 - 1980) was an Austrian pediatrician best known for his early studies on mental disorders in children, shares his name with Asperger's syndrome, a disorder characterized by social and cognitive difficulties.




  • Joseph Lister


    Sir Joseph Lister (1827 – 1912) is remembered as a proponent of antiseptic surgery and for the bacterial infection named after him, Listeriosis. Listerine mouthwash was also named after the sterile surgery pioneer.




  • John Langdon Down


    John Langdon Down (1828 – 1896), a British physician, gave his name to Down syndrome, a genetic disorder caused by the presence an extra chromosome.




  • Georges Gilles de la Tourette


    The French physician Georges Gilles de la Tourette (1857 – 1904) shares his name with Tourette syndrome, an inherited neuropsychiatric disorder characterized by physical and vocal tics.




  • Thomas Hodgkin


    Thomas Hodgkin (1798 – 1866) was an English physician who recorded the first account of a form of lymphoma, in 1832, now known as Hodgkin's disease.




  • Duchenne de Boulogne


    Duchenne de Boulogne (1806 - 1875) was a French neurologist for whom Duchenne muscular dystrophy, a disease that causes muscle degeneration and eventual death, is named.




  • Charles Bell


    The Scottish surgeon Charles Bell (1774 – 1842) discovered a form of facial paralysis that we now know as Bell's palsy.




  • Antoine Marfan


    French pediatrician Antoine Marfan (1858 - 1942) described a hereditary disorder of connective tissue in 1896. The disease, later named Marfan syndrome, can cause defects of the heart valves and aorta.




  • Carlos Chagas


    Carlos Chagas (1879–1934) was a Brazilian bacteriologist who discovered a tropical parasitic disease, in 1909, now known as Chagas disease.




  • François Gigot de la Peyronie


    The French surgeon François Gigot de la Peyronie (1678 – 1747) shares his name with Peyronie's Disease, a connective tissue disorder of the penis that causes pain, abnormal curvature, and erectile dysfunction.




  • Guillaume Dupuytren


    Guillaume Dupuytren (1777 – 1835), a French anatomist, described a flexion of the hand, in 1831, now known as Dupuytren's contracture.




  • Myrtelle Canavan


    Myrtelle Canavan (1879 - 1953), an American physician, is known for publishing a description of Canavan's disease, a degenerative disorder that causes gradual brain damage.




  • George Huntington


    George Huntington (1850 – 1916) was an American physician who described a neurodegenerative genetic disorder that causes cognitive decline and leads to psychiatric problems, now known as Huntington's disease.




  • Sir David Bruce


    Sir David Bruce (1855 - 1931) was a Scottish pathologist after whom brucellosis, a highly contagious bacterial disease, is named.




  • Harvey Williams Cushing


    Harvey Williams Cushing (1869 – 1939) was an American neurosurgeon and the first to describe Cushing's syndrome, the symptoms of prolonged exposure to high levels of the hormone cortisol.




  • Victor Babeș


    Victor Babeș (1854 – 1926) was a Romanian physician who discovered the cause of a rare tick-borne illness, what we now call babesiosis.




  • Paul Ehrlich


    Paul Ehrlich (1854 - 1915) was a German physician and Nobel Prize laureate for whom Ehrlichosis, a tick-borne bacterial infection, is named.




  • James Paget


    James Paget (1814 - 1899) was an English pathologist best known for studying Paget's disease, a chronic bone disease.




  • Philippe Gaucher


    Philippe Gaucher (1854 - 1918) was a French dermatologist best remembered for his description of Gaucher's disease, a genetic disorder of the liver and spleen.




  • Gerhard Armauer Hansen


    Gerhard Armauer Hansen (1841 – 1912), a Norwegian physician, identified the bacterium <em>Mycobacterium leprae</em> now known to cause Hansen's disease, also known as leprosy.




  • Moritz Kaposi


    Moritz Kaposi (1837 - 1902), a Hungarian dermatologist, is best known for his discovery of a form of skin cancer we now call Kaposi's sarcoma.




  • William Boog Leishman


    William Boog Leishman (1865 – 1926) was a Scottish pathologist for whom Leishmaniasis, a disease contracted from protozoan parasites that causes skin sores, is named.




  • Prosper Ménière


    The French physician Prosper Ménière (1799 – 1862) contributed to the identification of Ménière disease, a disorder of the inner ear that can affect hearing and balance.




  • Thomas Addison


    The English physician Thomas Addison (1793 – 1860), not to be confused with Thomas Edison, discovered a rare degenerative illness of the adrenal glands that can lead to very low blood pressure and even coma, now known as Addison's disease.